Why Quality Systems Stall: Four Gaps Between Structure And Improvement
Dr. Fatema Huzaifa, PhDFounder & Principal Consultant · 7 min read · November 2026
Over the past two decades, quality assurance has become a fixture of higher education. Most institutions now have a quality office, written policies and evidence prepared for every review. Yet the literature has long warned that formal structures do not guarantee better teaching and learning (Harvey & Green, 1993; Newton, 2000). Doctoral research across eight universities in Pakistan found the same pattern, and traced it to four recurring gaps (Huzaifa, 2025). This article outlines each gap and what institutions can do about it.
01Policy Vs. Practice
National frameworks and institutional strategies are often well designed. The difficulty lies in implementation. Neo-institutional theory offers one explanation: organisations under external pressure tend to adopt the visible structures expected of them, sometimes without changing the work those structures are meant to govern (Meyer & Rowan, 1977). In quality assurance, this appears as policies that are approved and filed, but rarely translated into actions that reach departments and classrooms.
A practical test is whether each quality policy can be traced to a named action, an owner and a timeline. Where it cannot, a Theory of Change approach, which links each intended outcome to specific activities and measures, offers a way to close the gap.
Adopting a structure is not the same as changing practice.
02Compliance Over Culture
When quality work is organised around external review, it tends to peak before each visit and fade afterwards. Newton (2000) described how academics can come to see quality monitoring as a ‘beast’ that must be ‘fed’ with ritual activity, rather than as a route to better teaching. The concept of quality culture emerged in response, shifting attention from procedures to shared values and commitment (EUA, 2006; Harvey & Stensaker, 2008).
For institutions, the telling question is whether improvement actions are still being tracked months after a review, or only revisited when the next one approaches.
Quality that lives only in review season is compliance, not culture.
03External Vs. Internal
International frameworks such as the European Standards and Guidelines treat internal and external quality assurance as parts of one system, with internal processes as the foundation (ENQA et al., 2015). Pakistan’s PSG-2023 follows a similar logic (HEC, 2023). In practice, however, many institutions run the two separately: one set of evidence for external accreditors and another for internal review.
The result is a doubled workload and fragmented evidence that never tells one clear story. Mapping external standards to internal processes once, and maintaining a single body of evidence, allows both to serve the same purpose: improvement.
04Low Ownership
Stakeholder theory holds that organisations perform better when those affected by decisions help to shape them (Freeman, 1984). In quality assurance, however, ownership often rests with the quality office alone. The doctoral research found low faculty engagement, limited student awareness, and quality staff without the authority, resources or training to lead (Huzaifa, 2025).
Newton’s (2002) study of academics ‘coping with quality’ points to the same risk: when staff are positioned as recipients of policy, quality becomes something done to them rather than by them.
Quality improves when people own it, not when they are asked to prove it.
Where To Start
These gaps rarely appear alone, and none of them requires a new structure. Each requires existing structures to work as one system. A structured diagnostic, such as the QART Framework, can show which gaps matter most in a given institution, and a Theory of Change plan can sequence the response. The aim is not more quality assurance, but quality assurance that leads to improvement.
References
- ENQA, ESU, EUA & EURASHE. (2015). Standards and guidelines for quality assurance in the European Higher Education Area (ESG). Brussels.
- European University Association. (2006). Quality culture in European universities: A bottom-up approach. Brussels: EUA.
- Freeman, R. E. (1984). Strategic management: A stakeholder approach. Boston: Pitman.
- Harvey, L., & Green, D. (1993). Defining quality. Assessment & Evaluation in Higher Education, 18(1), 9–34.
- Harvey, L., & Stensaker, B. (2008). Quality culture: Understandings, boundaries and linkages. European Journal of Education, 43(4), 427–442.
- Higher Education Commission. (2023). Pakistan precepts, standards and guidelines for quality assurance in higher education (PSG-2023), Ver. 1.0. Islamabad: Quality Assurance Agency, HEC.
- Huzaifa, F. (2025). A holistic exploration of quality assurance mechanisms at systemic and institutional levels: Conceptualization, perception, and practices in Pakistani higher education institutions [Doctoral thesis]. The British University in Dubai.
- Meyer, J. W., & Rowan, B. (1977). Institutionalized organizations: Formal structure as myth and ceremony. American Journal of Sociology, 83(2), 340–363.
- Newton, J. (2000). Feeding the beast or improving quality? Academics’ perceptions of quality assurance and quality monitoring. Quality in Higher Education, 6(2), 153–163.
- Newton, J. (2002). Views from below: Academics coping with quality. Quality in Higher Education, 8(1), 39–61.

